Abandonment – Negligence

A doctor has every right to refuse a patient, except in an emergency. But once he accepts, he cannot abandon. Where does a doctor's legitimate absence end and negligence begin? The answer lies in the doctor-patient relationship, informed consent and proper deputation.

Abandonment – Negligence
"Push will get a person almost anywhere — except through a door marked 'pull.'"

Abandonment – Negligence

It is true that a doctor has "Duties" in medical service, but he has certain "Rights" too. Every doctor has a right to refuse to treat any person, except in an emergency. That is non-acceptance. But once he has accepted the patient, it is his duty not to abandon him. The two look alike from the patient's bed, yet in law they are poles apart.

It is a hard fact that medical service runs 24 hours a day and 7 days a week. The doctor, however, is a social animal. He has to go out of town, or even abroad, for family, social or academic purposes. In spite of this, a common allegation is that "the doctor left the patient during treatment and it resulted in complication or death." When is that allegation good in law, and when is it merely convenient?

Key Takeaways

  • Non-acceptance of a person as a patient is a doctor's right (except in an emergency); abandonment of an accepted patient is negligence.
  • The key is the doctor-patient relationship: no relationship, no duty, and no question of breach.
  • Abandonment is the unilateral termination of that relationship while the patient still needs care, without his consent and without reasonable notice.
  • A doctor may be absent, but only after informing the patient and deputing a competent, equally qualified doctor. He remains liable for the negligence of his deputy.
  • Small nursing homes in remote areas cannot be judged by the standards of corporate hospitals in big cities.
  • A justified referral is not abandonment, but the duty continues until the other hospital accepts the patient.
  • The patient must still prove that the abandonment caused him injury.

Non-Acceptance Is Not Abandonment

There is a big difference between non-acceptance of a person as a patient and abandonment of a patient. The key is the doctor-patient relationship. In the former case the relationship is never established, so the question of duty and breach does not arise. In the latter it has been established. For this reason alone, non-acceptance is not negligence, but abandonment is.

The dictionary gives "abandon" two meanings: "give up completely or before completion" and "give up to another's control or mercy." Both fit medical practice rather well.

Once the doctor-patient relationship is established, the duty to treat that ailment starts, and it ends when the ailment is cured. For a new ailment, the relationship has to be established afresh, and the doctor can refuse.


What Amounts to Abandonment

The allegation is most common with indoor patients. Once a patient is admitted under the care of a doctor, whether in his own nursing home or in a hospital to which he is attached, it is his duty to treat that patient until he is properly discharged, transferred, or his life comes to an end. The monetary aspect is irrelevant. In outdoor cases, the doctor is duty-bound to treat the patient for that particular ailment till the end.

In medical practice, abandonment can be summarised as follows:

  • It is the unilateral and negligent termination of the doctor-patient relationship by the treating doctor,
  • at a time when the patient was in need of continuing medical care,
  • without the patient's consent, and
  • without reasonable or adequate notification.

Two more situations deserve mention. Providing inadequate care also amounts to abandonment. And the rule is not confined to doctors: an ambulance crew that leaves a patient in an emergency room without ensuring that the staff there has taken over treatment has abandoned him.


Two Kinds of Hospitals, Two Yardsticks

The law should take note of the hard fact that our country has mainly two types of indoor facilities.

Small hospitals

These are nursing homes, maternity homes or surgical homes, usually run by a single doctor. Most are in small towns and rural areas, some in truly remote ones. Qualified or trained staff is difficult to get. A blood bank, CT scan, MRI, ICU and even some medicines may not be available. Even another qualified doctor for deputation may not be available!

Therefore, one should not compare such a hospital with the corporate hospital of a big city. Actually, people should thank the doctors who run hospitals in remote areas at the cost of their personal, family and social life.

Often in such hospitals the surgeon and the anaesthetist come from a nearby town, even at odd hours. They leave after completing their job successfully, and the competent owner then looks after the patient. In the given circumstances, this does not amount to negligence.

Here also, however, the doctor should not leave the hospital after a procedure or operation until the patient is stable. If he must leave for some valid reason, he is bound to depute a qualified doctor, and he will be liable for the negligence of that deputy.

Multi-speciality and corporate hospitals

This includes Government, charitable and all other big hospitals. Here things are different. Such a hospital must have all the facilities and qualified staff round the clock. The consultant admits the patient under his care, and the patient is treated under his supervision by the supporting staff of the hospital.

This does not mean that the consultant has a free hand! He must leave the patient in the care of qualified juniors and staff, and it is his duty to supervise them. If something goes wrong, even the principle of res ipsa loquitur could be applied: the consultant has to explain, and if he fails to explain, he will be held liable.

Sometimes a patient is under the joint care of more than one doctor, in the ward or in the operation theatre. None of them can leave the patient halfway unless his own part is over or another doctor has taken over. Note that the co-doctors may also be held negligent if they do not take proper steps to fill the vacancy.


The Doctor's Absence

A doctor should not accept a patient when he knows that he has to go out of station, unless he informs the patient about it and suggests the alternative. If the patient agrees, then and only then should he be admitted. Even so, the doctor has to make a proper alternative arrangement for the period of his absence, and he remains liable for the negligence of the deputed doctor.

Ideally, in a planned absence, the patient is told before admission and his consent is taken. But the doctor also has family and social responsibilities, and to fulfil them in an emergency he sometimes has to leave. Here he should inform the patient and depute a competent doctor to take care in his absence.

It is needless to say that the deputation must be to a competent and equally qualified person, and that the doctor should see that the deputy actually does his duty. And if the patient is serious and in need of continuous monitoring by the doctor himself, the doctor has to keep his personal commitments aside.

Visiting doctors

India is becoming a medical hub. Foreign surgeons come here to treat patients, and eminent Indian super-specialists move all over the country. They are "visiting doctors," not employees of the hospital. Post-operative or post-procedural care is taken by the competent and qualified doctors of the hospital, and in most cases the patients are aware of this fact.

Even so, it is the duty of these consultants to check the patient before leaving the hospital. If any patient requires his expertise, he should not leave. Further, he must give written instructions to the doctors who are going to take over the post-procedural care.

Changing jobs

Often a doctor leaves one hospital and joins another. It is his right. It is not abandonment.


Abandonment on the Operation Table

Once the surgeon accepts a patient for surgical treatment, it is his duty to provide pre-operative, per-operative and post-operative care.

Pre-operative

Once the patient is found fit and the date of surgery is fixed, not operating on that day without a valid reason amounts to abandonment. The surgeon cannot go beyond the consent, and that too for some personal reason!

Per-operative

Often, for medical reasons, an operation has to be left halfway in the interest of the patient. That is not abandonment. The burden, however, is upon the surgeon to explain the medical reasons for which the operation was abandoned.

If the operation was left halfway because of some mistake on the part of the surgeon, it amounts to negligence. Here too res ipsa loquitur could be applied, and if the reason remains unexplained, it is abandonment.

Post-operative

The duty extends up to the complete recovery of the patient from the surgical trauma.


Referral: Shifting Is Not Always Deserting

Sometimes a patient deteriorates, or develops complications not related to the ailment, despite standard treatment. He then has to be referred to a higher centre for better treatment, and that does not amount to negligence. On the other hand, if the patient is constrained to be shifted because of some act or omission on the part of the doctor, that is abandonment.

In either case, it is the duty of the referring doctor to arrange safe shifting of the patient. His duty is not complete until the other hospital accepts the patient.


When the Patient Abandons the Doctor

If the patient himself does not continue the treatment, or does not follow the advice given, it is he who has abandoned the treatment. For that, only he can be blamed.

The patient also has to prove that he has suffered injury because of the abandonment by the doctor. If there is no injury, there cannot be actionable negligence on the part of the doctor.


Issues to Be Framed

When abandonment is alleged, four questions decide the matter:

  1. Did the doctor knowingly accept the patient?
  2. Did he take informed consent, including consent for his absence?
  3. Did he depute a qualified person?
  4. Did the patient suffer because of it?

What the Regulators Say

Medical Council of India: Code of Ethics Regulations, 2002

Regulation 2.4, The Patient must not be neglected: "A physician is free to choose whom he will serve. He should, however, respond to any request for his assistance in an emergency. Once having undertaken a case, the physician should not neglect the patient, nor should he withdraw from the case without giving adequate notice to the patient and his family. Provisionally or fully registered medical practitioner shall not wilfully commit an act of negligence that may deprive his patient or patients from necessary medical care."

Regulation 2.5, Engagement for an Obstetric case: when the engaged physician is absent and another is sent for and the delivery accomplished, the acting physician is entitled to his professional fees, but should secure the patient's consent to resign on the arrival of the physician engaged.

Regulation 4.4, Appointment of Substitute: the substitute should accept the appointment only when he has the capacity to discharge the additional responsibility along with his other duties.

Read together, the Code says in three regulations what this article says in many paragraphs: free to choose, bound to continue, and careful in substitution.

General Medical Council (U.K.)

The GMC emphasises the individual responsibility of a doctor to make appropriate arrangements for his indoor and outdoor patients:

"You must be satisfied that, when you are off duty, suitable arrangements are made for your patient's medical care. These arrangements should include effective handover procedures and clear communication between doctors. If you arrange cover for your own practice, you must satisfy yourself that doctors who stand in for you have the qualifications, experience, knowledge and skill to perform the duties for which they will be responsible. Deputizing doctors and locums are directly accountable to GMC for the care of patients while on duty."


Conclusion

The law does not ask the doctor to give up his family, his conferences or his sleep. It asks for three things only: tell the patient, take his consent, and hand him over to a competent pair of hands. A doctor who does this has exercised his right. A doctor who simply disappears has committed abandonment, and no amount of pushing will get him through that door.

Patients, of course, describe the disappearing act in their own way: "My doctor walked out of the room four hours ago, and I'm starting to think I'm now the head of this department."


About the Author

Dr. Mahendra K. Joshi, M.S. (General Surgery), LL.M. (Criminology), M.A.S.L.M.E. (USA)

Ex. Member, State Consumer Commission — Gujarat

[email protected] | +91 98790 94226